10 Best Smudge-Proof and Water-Proof Eyeliner Pencils

Last Updated: January 1, 2020
best smudge proof eyeliner pencil
Image: gettyimages

Eyeliner has always been a favorite item to enhance beauty. Ancient Egypt and Mesopotamia also have a history of using eyeliner not only for aesthetic purposes but also to save the skin from the desert sun. People from the past also put eyeliner as protection from evil!

Time has changed, but eyeliner remains the hot favorite. Eyes get a new definition using eyeliners. Hot sexy cat eye, aggravated drama look or subtle sweet style- eyeliners make you a new person with a few strokes. Modern technology has made eyeliner more advanced and skin friendly. New colors and an easy application will catch attention. But, one tiny problem remains. That is, SMUDGE!!!

[ Read Also: 10 best creams to remove dark circles ]

Hate it the most when the color around the eyes go out of line making you look like a stray cat or that you’ve been crying all night. So, here are 10 best smudge-free and long-lasting eyeliner pencils for you that won’t get ruined even if the mercury goes up.

The best smudge-proof, kiss-proof, and water-proof eyeliner pencil

1. Maybelline New York Master Drama EyelinerBest Eyeliner Pencil That Doesn’t Smudge

It is a new modernized creamy pencil eyeliner for the new generation by the worldwide known brand, Maybelline New York. Super easy to use, corner to corner continuous, skip-proof glided touch and 24 hours smudge free guarantee will impress you. Maybelline New York Master Drama Eyeliner will give you an intense dramatic eye look with a bold color around the edges. It is water resistant and does not smudge. Ophthalmologist tested for sensitive skin and lens wearer.

Buy It on Amazon

2. e. l. f. Cream EyelinerBest Eyeliner Pencil That Doesn’t Smudge

This creamy formula is designed to give you, you’re desired thin or bold lines. It creates smooth lines that are defined and precise. The e. l. f. Cream Eyeliner will put up all day against sweat, tears or rain. It will not smudge or budge and remain the same as you put it at first. This easy-to-apply product comes with a slanted eyeliner brush for better use and more design around the eyes. You will have more beautiful eyes.

Buy It on Amazon

[ Read Also: 10 best drugstore eyeliners over $20 ]

3. MIA ADORA Tattoo Effect Eyeliner PencilBest Eyeliner Pencil That Doesn’t Smudge

Whether the skies pour down or mercury goes high, your MIA ADORA Tattoo Effect Eyeliner will not let you down. Its easy application makes it a great choice for the new applies. Apply it once and don’t even need to check it, let alone re-apply. Your eyes will look the same and it will not smudge. High precision and easy continuous glide touch will help you to get the look of the day. Ophthalmologist tested, safe for sensitive skin and contact lens wearers.

Buy It on Amazon

4. L’Oreal Paris Pencil Perfect Self-Advancing Eyeliner in ExpressoBest Eyeliner Pencil That Doesn’t Smudge

This product gives you a pencil perfect line for your eyes. Its creamy formula glides on smoothly, softly and perfectly without any problem. L’Oreal Paris Pencil Perfect Self-Advancing Eyeliner in Expresso doesn’t wear off easily and stays all day. It’s completely smudge-free and no jagged lines; so your look will not be spoiled. It is tested by the ophthalmologists for allergies and sensitive skin. So, even lens wearer can apply it happily. It is also fragrance-free.

Buy It on Amazon

5. KissMe Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner Pencil in BlackBest Eyeliner Pencil That Doesn’t Smudge

This product is especially fine for oily skin. Wash your face before applying and it will last a whole day. It is smudge-proof in water tears, sweat, sebum and kisses. The tip is ultra-fine; so, it can draw up to 0.1 mm thin line making out a dense clear stroke, strong lines, and an impressive highlight. KissMe Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner in Black is easy to apply and the fine tip will help you to get any look within minutes.

Buy It on Amazon

[ Read Also: 10 best SPF under eye creams ]

6. L’Oreal Paris Infallible Never Fail Eyeliner Pencil in BlackBest Eyeliner Pencil That Doesn’t Smudge

This amazing eyeliner has a very rich creamy formula. It comes with an inbuilt sharpener. L’Oreal Paris Infallible Never Fail Eyeliner in Black is a product that doesn’t smudge easily and lasts 16 hours long. The creamy formula glides easily and sets on perfectly around your eyes. It will give you a long-lasting and water-proof rich color and fine appearance with a few strokes for any occasion. It will surely turn into your must-have makeup item.

Buy It on Amazon

7. Katherine Cosmetics Everyday Eyeliner Pencil in Cessna BrownBest Eyeliner Pencil That Doesn’t Smudge

It is made with all natural ingredients and contains antioxidants, Vitamin E and C, Defensil and Hyaluronic Acid. This smudge proof, long lasting, waterproof and sweatproof eyeliner is gluten, paraben, and fragrance-free too. It’s tested by the ophthalmologist and also for allergy and any other reaction free. It’s retractable and has a built-in blending brush with an auto sharpening feature. Katherine Cosmetics Everyday Eyeliner in Cessna Brown gives you a precise application that glides smoothly on any skin for a perfect look.

Buy It on Amazon

8. Physicians Formula Eyeliner Pencil in Ultra BlackBest Eyeliner Pencil That Doesn’t Smudge

It is an innovative formula with a lash boosting formula that targets the base of lashes and enhances their growth. Changed appearance of lashes is visible within a few weeks. This hi-tech Japanese formula is long-wearing, water-resistant, kiss-proof, and smudge-resistant with the ultra-precise brush-tip easy application and provides an instant definition of liquid eyeliners. Physicians Formula Eyeliner in Ultra Black is allergy tested and dermatologist approved for sensitive skin and lens wearer. It is fragrance and paraben free formula for your makeup collection.

Buy It on Amazon

9. Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner PencilBest Eyeliner Pencil That Doesn’t Smudge

This award-winning rich color eyeliner will get stuck on your mind. Its vibrant appearance, easy to apply technique and long-lasting a smudge-free stay is sure to make Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner your hot favorite. This highly pigmented, waterproof eyeliner glides smoothly and provides an intense vibrant color for a long time. Smudge Sticks are now available in an array of matte, shimmer and pop hues that hold tight. It is made with moisturizing ingredients like vitamin E.

Buy It on Amazon

[ Read Also: 10 best under eye anti-aging serums ]

10. Prestige Total Intensity Eyeliner Pencil in Deepest BlackBest Eyeliner Pencil That Doesn’t Smudge

This eyeliner pencil gives you an intense finish on both top and bottom lashes. The bold lines stay up to 10 hours long. Prestige Total Intensity Eyeliner Long Lasting Intense Color does not smudge, fade away or spill with the contact of water. Smooth textures do not let you tug or pull the eyes. The product is dermatologically tested and suited for all skin types. As it is easy to use and has a vibrant appearance surely it’ll impress you.

Buy It on Amazon


Eyes can make out a definition for you. You don’t need to put on heavy makeup or fancy dress just color around the eyes and it will make you shine. With the incoming of more vibrant colors and new styles pick out which you like and make your statement. So, pick your favorite smudge-proof eyeliner pencil that can be your partner in the walkway.

How We Pick The Product

We recommend products by researching Amazon best-selling items, user’s reviews, YouTube reviews, talk show interviews, higher rated products, most reviewed items, celebrity gossip, daily publications, and magazine interviews with celebrity, dermatologist or doctor.

We research the product’s literature from the trusted sources. We frequently refer many leading publications – Elle, Allure, Cosmopolitan, She Knows, Good Housekeeping, Reader’s Digest, Best Reviews, Marie Claire, Women’s Health, Vouge, Buzzfeed, etc.

We also often analysis the product’s information from the reliable sources (who make the deep testing) like Cook’s Illustrated, America’s Test Kitchen, Consumer Reports, Consumer Testing Laboratories, etc.

It’s better to note that every product does not work for everyone. And the result may be different because of different skin tones, types, and conditions. So, often your dermatologist may give you the better recommendations which product you should use for your skin.


  1. I just tried Stila and it smudged big time. Was not impressed with the wear-ability. The color was great – just did not wear well as promised. I’m beginning to wonder if there is a TRUE Waterproof, Smudge-proof, Sweat-proof eyeliner anywhere in the marketplace. I would LOVE to find one . . . . and if it could be TEAR-proof as well. It seems nothing can withstand the power of TEARs.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.